流金岁月

乌军三任总司令对比，谁的兵法谋略最强？真相是全都水土不服,黑洞观星,原创乌军三任总司令对比，谁的兵法谋略最强？真相是全都水土不服_我的网站

兰陵王

一 |

Image of the PLA Navy Type 054A guided missile frigate Ningde Photo: China Military BugleState media released footage on Saturday showing the latest training scenes of the Type 054A guided missile frigate Ningde, marking its official commissioning into the Chinese People's Liberation Army (PLA) Navy.
The vessel inherits the hull number 510 from its predecessor, a smaller Type 056 guided missile corvette also named Ningde.
Recently, the Ningde, assigned to a frigate flotilla under the PLA Eastern Theater Command, formed a task group with multiple vessels to conduct combat-oriented training, testing command coordination and emergency response capabilities while accelerating combat readiness generation, according to the military channel of state broadcaster CCTV News.
As threats emerged from both sea and air, radar stations quickly locked onto targets and reported the tactical situation. Weapons systems prepared for engagement. Following the commander's order, the main and secondary guns opened fire in succession, delivering intensive strikes and neutralizing the simulated threats, the report said.
Amid rolling waves, the vessel conducted replenishment drills. Subsequently, the Ningde focused on specialized training in areas including helicopter takeoffs and landings and damage control, further honing its combat skills, said the report.
The new Ningde has drawn attention from Chinese military enthusiasts, who remarked that the PLA Navy's modernization is moving at an astonishing pace, as the previous Type 056 Ningde had been in service for only about a decade, according to Shanghai Observer.
The continued production and upgrade of the Type 054A have effectively filled the gap in coastal and offshore combat capabilities, providing the navy with a large number of cost-effective platforms for both near-sea and far-sea operations, helping maintain a sustained combat readiness, Zhang Junshe, a Chinese military affairs expert, told the Global Times on Sunday.
Mass production has reduced unit procurement and maintenance costs, standardized training, logistics and command systems, and significantly improved the overall efficiency of the Navy's equipment system, Zhang said.
The Type 054A guided missile frigate belongs to the PLA Navy's most numerous and cost-effective medium-sized frigate program of the past two decades, often described as a "maritime multi-role platform."
With the addition of the Ningde, the Type 054A fleet has now reached 46 vessels, Zhang said.
The Type 054A is equipped with 3D radar, low-altitude gap-filling radar and a towed array sonar system, forming a three-dimensional detection network covering sea, air and underwater domains. With a range of 4,000 nautical miles, it is suited for long-duration far-sea missions and possesses strong integrated combat capabilities in coastal and offshore waters, as well as far-sea escort capabilities. Its weapon systems are well balanced through successive upgrades, Zhang said.
In January 2026, CCTV announced a newly upgraded version of Type 054A frigates.
Compared with the original design, the upgraded version features an extended flight deck better suited for new shipborne helicopters, addressing a previous shortfall in aviation-based anti-submarine warfare. The main gun has also been upgraded to a 100mm caliber, similar to that on the Type 054B, with improved radar range and accuracy.
PLA Navy has developed the Type 054B frigate as a next-generation successor to the Type 054A.
On January 22, 2025, the lead ship of the Type 054B, Luohe, was commissioned at a naval port in Qingdao, East China's Shandong Province, followed by the second ship, Qinzhou, in March, reported CCTV.
The Type 054B frigate displaces approximately 5,000 tons and features a new propulsion system, stealth design, integrated mast and advanced multi-functional vertical launch system capable of firing various missile types. It has achieved breakthroughs in stealth technology, combat command systems and fire control integration, said the CCTV report.
Despite this, China continues to upgrade and build the Type 054A frigate. Zhang said that the Type 054A and Type 054B form a clear "high-low mix, mission complement" structure.
The Type 054B is positioned as a larger far-sea vessel, primarily tasked with core escort and high-end confrontation missions in far-sea formations. The Type 054A serves as the main coastal and offshore combat force and a supplementary far-sea asset, responsible for near-sea defense, routine patrols, anti-submarine warfare in offshore waters, and escort missions for far-sea formations. This avoids equipment homogenization and enables efficient synergy, Zhang said.
The Type 054A features mature technology, stable production lines, fast construction and high cost-effectiveness, enabling rapid mass deployment at relatively low cost. Meanwhile, the Type 054B, as a new model, still comes with a higher price tag.
Given the Navy's continuous demand for more vessels, continued construction of the Type 054A quickly fills the coastal and offshore capability gap, while the Type 054B gradually replaces some older vessels and enhances far-sea integrated combat capabilities, Zhang noted.
。如果单论兵法和谋略，乌军三任总司令哪个最强？其实三人各有所长，但是三位统帅又全都水土不服。

二 | 因为他们修炼多年的兵法，在俄乌战场无法施展。俄乌双方师出同门，学的都是苏系兵法。比如大兵团集群作战，行进间转换战斗队形，钢铁洪流加人海战术，还有著名的一字长蛇阵。结果双方交手之后，却打成了一战时期的阵地战，以前学的兵法都不管用了。所以单看战绩，这三位统帅还真不好作对比。关键要看不同的阶段，统帅所起的作用有多大。

三 | 今天就单论兵法谋略，看这三任统帅哪个最强？俄乌开战初期，乌军统帅是钢铁硬汉扎卢日内，扎卢日内临危受命，逆风翻盘。

四 | 接连赢得基辅保卫战，赫尔松战役，哈尔科夫反击战。特别是宏观调度方面，扎总司令眼光异常精准。如果不是扎总稳准狠的战略布局，大鹅就不止占领乌东四州了。要么已经全部占领小乌，要么已经占领第聂伯河东岸，绝没有现在的有利局面。

五 | 扎卢日内的战略眼光，无疑是三人中最高的。但扎总司令有个短板，指挥风格比较粗糙。

六 | 扎总制定完计划之后，往往就放手不管了，直接交给下面去执行。扎总只要求实现战略目标，没有对士兵伤亡严格管控。

七 | 由于苏系打法特别粗糙，结果导致乌军消耗过多。哪怕是一比二的战损比，小乌这边都算是血亏。欧盟发现乌军耗不过大鹅，所以迟迟不敢下场，对小乌的支援就像挤牙膏。一旦战场形势对乌军不利，司机必然被西方抛弃。所以司机才命令扎总进行反攻，让西方看到乌军的统战价值。没想到扎总拒绝大规模反攻，因为俄军早已在南部战场，打造了坚固的苏洛维金防线，大鹅本土又防的像铁桶一般。一旦乌军踢到铁板上，必然会损失惨重。

八 | 司机被逼无奈，只好罢免扎卢日内，换上听话的西尔斯基。西尔斯基打仗有两大特点，政治上特别听话，领导让干嘛就干嘛，哪怕是必输的仗也要打。军事上打法特别凶悍，凡是西尔斯基指挥的战役，都是杀伐果断刺刀见红。如果说扎卢日内擅长宏观布局，那西尔斯基更擅长局部操刀，亲自上阵指挥各种战役。从最初的安东诺夫机场战役，基辅保卫战，哈尔科夫反击战，一直到2026南线大反攻。西尔斯基几乎打遍全场，参与了所有的重大战役。特别是库尔斯克战役，更是俄乌战场的神来之笔。此战让欧盟彻底看清大鹅的虚弱，欧盟立马对小乌疯狂援助。促成了俄乌军事政治上的双重转折点。但随着川皇上台，老美开始打压小乌，此时大鹅也趁机疯狂反扑。西尔斯基只能采取保守打法，用铁桶防御来对抗大鹅。但这种打法西方和司机都不满意，于是西方支持的费多罗夫闪亮登场，以乌军升级改革为口号，要和西尔斯基争夺总司令。结果都看到了，两人被同时罢免，司机任命德拉帕特为总司令。在西尔斯基的任职履历中，能清晰看到他的指挥风格。特别擅长战役级别的正面对掏，但政治和战略视野存在短板。对于多次爆发的政治危机，都没有积极妥善处理。很多军事上的战略机遇，也没有及时抓住。以至于西尔斯基打的很吃力，虽然战术上一直赢，战略上却始终无法破局。接下来的局势发展，就看德拉帕特了。德拉帕特履历太新，甚至都查不到完整战绩。而且德拉帕特刚上任，就仓促发起库皮扬斯克大反攻。

九 | 以突击队硬刚俄军的坚固防线，这种仗很难有重大突破，弄不好还会损兵折将。不过新官上任三把火，只要没有重大翻车，也能够理解德拉帕特。不过最近战场形势的变化，让我对德拉帕特刮目相看。德拉帕特发现库皮扬斯克打不动，没有继续恋战。而是矛头一转，专门突击南线俄军的软肋。在第聂伯罗方向，乌军一次闪电突袭，就打崩一个集团军。导致俄军在南线苦战一年多，才得到的战略优势，一个月就被全部打破。此战证明德拉帕特被严重低估。虽然在战役操作层面，德拉帕特暂时不如西尔斯基。但在战略时机把控方面，德拉帕特明显高于西尔斯基。现在可以百分百确定，德拉帕特的指挥能力，肯定能超越前两任总司令。

十 | 因为德拉帕特还有个优势，那就是成长速度特别快，指挥上限特别高。在俄乌开战初期，德拉帕特只是一名中下级军官，属于冲锋陷阵型的猛将。

十一 | 短短四年时间，德拉帕特就已成长为一流统帅。综合评判乌军三任统帅，扎卢日内最具政治和战略眼光，短板是作战风格比较粗糙。西尔斯基最擅长指挥具体战役，但比较欠缺战略眼光。由于俄乌打成了阵地战和消耗战，导致两位统帅长处无法施展，面临水土不服的窘境。其实德拉帕特同样水土不服，不过德拉帕特有三大优点，一是成长性最快，上限很高。二是思想观念新奇，敢于打破常规。三是战略战术没有短板，而且攻守兼备。